They spent $111.5 million on advertising and marketing and lost 30,000 customers.
As a president of an ad agency, they should all be fired.
Typical of a bureaucracy, they think they did great. And they want more tax money.
Since they are unaccountable, the waste of tax money goes on.
Let’s look at this unreported failure.
Obamacare spent and wasted $10 million in advertising nationally for 2017-2018.
But that’s nothing compared to the outrageous waste of taxpayer money by the California government.
Covered California is California’s own healthcare exchange….an arm of the failing, messy system of Obamacare.
Covered California is riddled with problems… complications for consumers and rising premiums. Plus, low quality coverage and healthcare.
Despite all of this, they continue to spend tax money with little accountability.
Take Covered California’s whopping advertising budget, which just spent $111.5 million for 2017-2018. Approximately $45 million is devoted to ads, which includes:
– $18 million for TV
– $8 million for radio
– $9 million for digital ads
-$3.1 million for print ads
Compared to healthcare.gov – the national arm of Obamacare – Covered CA spent 10 times as much as states that participate in healthcare.gov, which has an advertising budget of $10 million.
Here are 3 disturbing things you need to know about this massive waste of $111.5 million.
- It’s an abuse of taxpayer dollars.
The huge $111.5 million-dollar budget has been explained as a solution to “consumer confusion” about Covered CA…but much of their marketing approach is a total waste of tax money.
As a 30-year ad vet, I’ve worked on hundreds of campaigns. This budget was bloated. A waste and quite frankly – as an 86-time winner of ad awards – ridiculous.
For example, Covered California’s freehanded and lazy approach to spending money on marketing even includes $100,000 for painted murals across the state…scenes that are irrelevant to insurance enrollment. One of the murals shows a woman with a bowl on her head, with children riding bikes and a basketball player coming out of it.
This is money that could have been spent on lowering premiums…but instead was used to commission public art that has little to do with health care.
Another marketing effort with questionable return on investment has been a Covered California bus tour that further promotes their message, “Life can change in an instant.”
This does nothing to explain how the system works, or to clear “consumer confusion.”
Much of the rest of the budget goes to navigators (people who help with sign-ups for Covered California) and staff budgets.
Tens of millions are being poured into their advertising, but is the budget being accounted for?
Let’s look at the results:
-During their open enrollment period, Covered CA gained 423,484 new customers—a 3% increase in enrollment over last year.
– However, total enrollment dropped 2.3% from 1.55 million in 2017 to 1.52 million in 2018.
– Covered CA spent $111.5 million and still lost 30,000 customers.
This is an embarrassing failure…and a shocking loss of taxpayer money, spent on unproductive and unaccountable marketing efforts.
And they should be fired.
But they won’t be.
They will ask for more money to “fix” the problem.
Covered California is one of 11 states (plus the District of Colombia), that has its own health care exchange.
The rest of the states use the healthcare.gov site, which has dramatically slashed its budget from $100 million to $10 million in their nationwide campaign in 2016. Healthcare.gov has also cut its budget for navigators, from $63 million to $37 million…a budget cut put into place under the Trump administration.
Healthcare.gov cut their budget…and also saw an approximately 4% decrease in enrollment, from 9.2 million to 8.8 million in 2018.
Note: 39% decrease in enrollment for California. 49% decrease in the other states: $111.5 million vs. $10 million.
In California, the marketing budget amounted to approximately $73.35 per enrolled person.
It’s a shocking misuse of money—a total waste of taxpayer dollars on Obamacare and its broken, corrupt branch, Covered California.
- $111.5 exceeds the marketing budgets of most major brands and advertisers.
Covered CA’s budget is comparable to the budgets of the most valuable brands in the world, who spend hundreds of millions of dollars a year on marketing—but also bring in billions in revenue.
Take a look at the following examples:
- Oracle – a database management company – spends $68 million on advertising and marketing….and makes $37.4 billion in revenue.
- Nissan spends only a fraction of the budget of Covered CA, at $26 million. They bring in $94.7 billion in revenue.
- Healthcare in California: $111.5 million is outrageous.
These companies are creating hundreds of thousands of jobs and rapidly innovating new products and services…Covered California, on the other hand, is an inefficient government agency that offers reduced health care quality and skyrocketing premiums.
And loses customers.
I’ve spent over 40 years as owner of a national ad agency.
I’d love a $111.5 million account.
But the reality for a marketing budget is lower, even for large companies.
$5-$25 million is considered a huge amount. Very few would even be able to justify going over this range unless you’re an arrogant bureaucrat spending others’ money.
- The Deep State is behind the scenes—trying to waste even more taxpayer dollars.
The most disturbing part is that Deep State politicians are working hard to pour even more money into this massive waste of taxpayer dollars.
Covered CA – and its parent system, Obamacare – are politically motivated, ideologically driven programs put into place to advance a socialist agenda and big government.
For example, when you sign up for Covered CA, you can also register to vote. No doubt that this process facilitates voter fraud in California—already a critical issue and dangerous threat to our voting system.
Deep State politicians want to funnel more funds into their political agenda, however…not to help people, but to promote progressive ideology.
Here’s a list of radically progressive foundations and groups that receive a massive amount of funding to advance their agenda:
- The East LA Community Corporation, which receives $980,000 annually
- The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) and American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organization (AFL/CIO), which receives $2 million
- The California Council of Churches, which receives $750,000
- The Actors Fund, which receives $435,000
- Planned Parenthood, which receives $694,000 yearly
- Asian Americans Advancing Justice receive $1 million
- The Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, receiving $940,000
- The L.A. Gay & Lesbian Center, which receives $1 million
- Community organization/Voter registration – $68 million
The Deep State makes sure that our taxpayer dollars are spent on promoting their interests…and their radically progressive/socialist agenda for the nation.
The Deep State is fighting back…hard. They want to keep in place bloated, government-run agencies with massive budgets and political agendas—with little concern for taxpayer dollars.
What do you think? Write me at [email protected]